Question for Physiotherapists
Chondral Grafting in the knee
CHONDRAL GRAFTING OF THE KNEE:
Articular cartilage injuries in the knee are common and unfortunately the cartilage does not heal or regenerate. They are usually from twisting injuries during sport or work which cause a shearing or impact injury to the knee.
Cartilage injuries in the knee are common and can occur in isolation or in combination with limb malalignment, meniscus, ligament, and bone deficiencies. Each of these problems must be addressed to achieve a successful outcome for any cartilage restoration procedure.
More significant osteochondral injuries that penetrate the subchondral bone can lead to fibrous or fibrocartilageneous healing. This led to a procedure called Marrow stimulation or microfracture where holes are drilled into the subchondral bone to allow the adjacent marrow (rich in blood cells and pluripotent cells) to fill the overlying chondral defect and hopefully allow it to heal. While this works well it does not work for everyone and is not always long lasting.
Patients complain of swelling, pain or locking in the knee which is worse with activity and does not respond to the usual treatments such as NSAIDS or physiotherapy. These injuries tend to progress and result in degenerative arthritis of the knee.
Articular cartilage injury is a common finding at arthroscopy but only about 5% of patients are suitable for some form of chondral grafting. Cartilage surgery should be targeted at reducing symptoms and on improving functional daily activities rather than as a method of returning to high-level sports participation for competitive athletes with chondral damage.
Injuries that are most appropriate for treatment are full-thickness lesions more than 2 cm2 in size in a patient <40 years of age.
Some patients who have isolated chondral lesions (and radiographic arthritis) are still able to live their lives with very few symptoms and some are even able to play regular impact loading sports. Progression of the chondral lesion may depend on it’s size and location, the status of the underlying bone, the presence of arthritis; and patient factors such as age, limb alignment, joint stability and body mass index. Chondral grafting should only be considered if patients have ongoing symptoms after their initial arthroscopy. It should not be performed as a ‘preventive’ measure.
Articular cartilage lacks a direct vascular supply and nutrients are therefore delivered via the synovial fluid. Diffusion of this fluid through the cartilage requires an intact solid matrix of cells and three main techniques have been developed to ‘restore’ cartilage to the damaged area. These are 1) Microfracture 2) OAT and 3) Thermogel application.
- Microfracture is the first-line treatment option for full-thickness articular cartilage defects because it is minimally invasive, technically easy, has limited surgical morbidity and is low cost. The lesion is debrided, the zone of calcified cartilage is removed and cortical penetration is achieved with an awl, causing medullary bleeding and clot formation. The literature shows clear improvement in knee function at 24 months but inconclusive durability beyond the 2 year mark.
- OAT or mosaicplasty involves harvesting viable, structurally intact cartilage and bone plugs from a “less valuable” portion of the knee joint and transplanting that material to the site of symptomatic cartilage injury. Rapid healing and incorporation of the bone plug occurs and the articular gaps fill with fibrous tissue. There are many problems with this technique including: creating symptoms in another part of the knee, thin articular cartilage is used to replace thick cartilage; and the fact that relatively flat cartilage is usually placed on a very rounded surface.
- Application of a thermo-gel device. The hope is that it will physically stabilize the clot that forms and guide and enhance marrow-derived repair. The main ingredient of this device is Chitosan. Chitosan is a linear polysaccharide made by treating the chitin shells of shrimp and other crustaceans with an alkaline substance, like sodium hydroxide. It can be used in agriculture as a seed treatment and bio-pesticide, helping plants to fight off fungal infections. In winemaking it can be used as a fining agent, also helping to prevent spoilage. In industry, it can be used in a self-healing polyurethane paint In medicine, it may be useful in bandages to reduce bleeding and as an antibacterial agent; it can also be used to help deliver drugs through the skin. The haemostatic agent works by an interaction between the cell membrane of erythrocytes (negative charge) and the protonated chitosan (positive charge) leading to involvement of platelets and rapid thrombus formation.
The primary goals for a rehabilitation program are to allow local adaptation and remodelling of the repair with return to function. The problem is that each injury and surgery is different so standardised protocols are not very useful.
The main components of any rehabilitation program are: progressive weight bearing, restoration of range of motion and finally muscle control, proprioceptive retraining, and strengthening.
Since the repair site is at its most vulnerable during the first 3 months it is important to avoid impact as well as excessive loading and shearing forces during this time. Since shear forces have to be minimized, the size and location of the defect have to be known because during several activities only parts of the femur/tibia are articulating. For example, the posterior aspect of the medial femur condyle contacts the tibia between 90° and 120°; therefore, loading in positions between 0° and 80° of knee flexion are unlikely to damage a graft in this area.
Neuromuscular control and retraining involves varying movement speed from slow movements that target the feedback system in the early stages of rehabilitation through progressions to quick movements that focus more on retraining the feed-forward system in the later stages of rehabilitation.
Hydrotherapy – Exercises under water produce lower electromyography (EMG) activity during isometric and dynamic conditions when compared to similar exercises on land, thereby leading to lower joint forces. Research has shown that an early and intensive application of hydrotherapy for improving coordination and strength during rehabilitation is helpful. In addition, moving in water gives patients a “feeling of freedom” which seems to be an important psychological advantage.
Therapeutic Ultrasound and Laser – Low-intensity pulsed ultrasound (LIPUS) and low-level laser therapy have been proposed as providing appropriate stimuli for the acceleration of chondrogenesis. The initial findings are quite promising.
Neuromuscular electrical stimulation is mainly useful in patients who are poorly motivated, have long-term muscle weakness, or are slow responders (active exercises work just as well in the majority of people).
Cycling Increases in the cycling workload result in a significant increase in knee load-moments and compressive and shear forces, but increases in the pedalling rate do not appear to affect the maximum knee load-moment. Use low resistance stationary bike when ROM good enough.
Low-impact exercise on elliptical trainers, cross-trainers and ski trainers are closed kinetic chain activities but the implications for loading on the knee joint are not fully understood and must be used with caution early on.
Generally, low-impact sports and exercise such as swimming, cycling, and golf can usually be resumed within 6 months. Racquet sports, team sports, martial arts, and running can range from an early postoperative return or take up to 12 – 18 months.
Post Operative Care
Rehabilitation following a thermo-gel application begins the day after the surgery. The knee is splinted in extension for 24 hours to allow the clot to mature. Depending on the location of the lesion weight bearing may be possible and CPM might be used after that. The frequency, duration, and ROM will depend on the location and size of the lesion. Active and passive motion is also utilized to facilitate the integration of the graft into the surrounding articular cartilage and subchondral bone.
Most patients will be on crutches for 6 weeks as the medial femoral condyle is the most commonly injured site. If the procedure is combined with a high tibial osteotomy, 3 months total crutch use may be required with partial weight bearing for 6 weeks.
The goal is to eventually provide cyclical compression and decompression to allow mechanical stimulation of the graft to promote chondrocyte growth. This includes reducing pain and oedema, addressing soft tissue adaptive changes, restoring muscle strength and function, and gradually including progressive resisted exercise to allow a return to the prior level of function. Generally speaking younger, more active patients have better outcomes in all of these groups.
Rehabilitation following ANY articular cartilage repair procedure is long and demanding. This varies with the size and location of the lesion as well as anything else that was required at the operation such as a high tibial osteotomy. It is hoped that in the future mesenchymal stem cells will be available for Cartilage Regeneration but currently only the techniques listed in this article are available.
I am currently involved in a research study recruiting patient’s who have suffered a chondral injury to their knee. The purpose of this research study is to determine whether knee cartilage injuries heal better with a microfracture procedure or with a microfracture procedure and a thermo-gel device. The thermo-gel device is designed to improve the quantity and quality of repaired cartilage tissue, as well as improve joint function and reduce pain from the knee. The device is currently approved for use by the Therapeutic Goods Administration in Australia and multiple other countries. If the patient is eligible and chooses to join the study, they will have a mixture of standard of care and study visits throughout their rehabilitation.
Please contact me through my office if you would like to see if your patients will be eligible for the study.
Dr Doron Sher
M.B., B.S. (NSW), M.Biomed.E., F.R.A.C.S. (Ortho.)
Knee, Shoulder and Elbow Surgeon
Orthosports Randwick: (02) 9399 5333
Orthosports Concord: (02) 9744 2666
Previous Question for Physiotherapists:
|Dec-2020||Wrist Ganglions||Dr Kwan Yeoh|
|Oct/Nov-2020||Medial Meniscal Root Tears||Dr Doron Sher|
|Sep-2020||Lumbar Stress Fractures||Dr Paul Annett|
|Aug-2020||Frailty and Healthy Ageing||Dr John Best|
|Jul-2020||Thumb – Collateral Ligament Tear||Dr Kwan Yeoh|
|Jun-2020||Shoulder Instability||Dr Doron Sher|
|May-2020||Hallux Rigidus||Dr John Negrine|
|Mar/Apr-2020||Achilles Tendon Ruptures||Dr Todd Gothelf|
|Feb-2020||Distal Biceps||Dr Doron Sher|
|Nov-2019||Clavicle Fracture Internal Fixation||Dr Doron Sher|
|Oct-2019||Femoracetabular Impingement (FAI)||Dr Paul Mason|
|Sep-2019||Imaging for Acute ACL Injuries||Dr Doron Sher|
|Aug-2019||Joint Relocation||Dr Paul Annett|
|Jul-2019||Guyon canal surgery||Dr Kwan Yeoh|
|Jun-2019||Whats new in ACL reconstruction 2019||Dr Doron Sher|
|May-2019||Cuneiform Fracture||Dr Todd Gothelf|
|Apr-2019||Flexor Tendon Injuries||Dr Kwan Yeoh|
|Mar-2019||Chronic Exertional Compartment Synd||Dr Paul Annett|
|Feb-2019||Achilles Tendon Rupture||Dr John Negrine|
|Nov-2018||Low Back Pain||Dr Paul Mason|
|Sep-2018||Concussion part 2||Dr John Best|
|Jul-2018||Concussion part1||Dr Paul Annett|
|Jun-2018||Thessaly & McMurray Test||Dr Doron Sher|
|May-2018||AC Joint||Dr Doron Sher|
|Apr-2018||Arthritis of the fingers||Dr Kwan Yeoh|
|Feb-2018||CLAVICLE fractures||Dr Doron Sher|
|Oct-2017||ACL Grafts||Dr Doron Sher|
|Sep-2017||Forefoot pain||Dr John Negrine|
|Aug-2017||Wrist Ganglion||Dr Kwan Yeoh|
|Jul-2017||Anterolateral Ligament Reconstruction||Dr Doron Sher|
|Jun-2017||Scapholunate ligament||Dr Kwan Yeoh|
|Apr-2017||Knee Brace – ACL Reconstruction||Dr Doron Sher|
|Mar-2017||Sesamoid fractures||Dr Kwan Yeoh|
|Feb-2017||Plantar Fasciitis||Dr Todd Gothelf|
|Nov-2016||Sternoclavicular Joint||Dr Doron Sher|
|Oct-2016||Proximal Humerus Fractures||Dr David Lieu|
|Sep-2016||Wrist Fractures||Dr Kwan Yeoh|
|Aug-2016||Patella Instability||Dr Doron Sher|
|Jul-2016||Snowboarders ankle||Dr Todd Gothelf|
|May-2016||Cortisone Injections||Dr Paul Annett|
|Apr-2016||Shoulder Instability_1||Dr Ivan Popoff|
|Mar-2016||Exercise after TKR||Dr Doron Sher|
|Dec-2015||Scaphoid OA||Dr Kwan Yeoh|
|Nov-2015||Greater Tuberosity Fractures||Dr Doron Sher|
|Oct-2015||Stress Fractures||Dr Paul Annett|
|Sep-2015||Boxers Fractures||Dr Kwan Yeoh|
|Aug 2015||Resistance Training||Dr John Best|
|July 2015||LARS Ligament||Dr Ivan Popoff|
|Jun-2015||Distal Biceps||Dr Doron Sher|
|May-2015||Latarjet procedure||Dr Jerome Goldberg|
|Apr-2015||TFCC Questions||Dr Kwan Yeoh|
|Mar-2015||Acute Ankle Sprains||Dr Todd Gothelf|
|Nov-2014||PRPP||Dr Paul Annett|
|Oct-2014||Driving After Surgery||Dr Doron Sher|
|Sep-2014||Distal Biceps Rupture||Dr Doron Sher|
|Aug-2014||Ankle Sprain||Dr Todd Gothelf|
|Jun-2014||Patella Dislocation||Dr Doron Sher|
|May-2014||Shoulder Instability||Dr Todd Gothelf|
|Apr-2014||De Quervains||Dr Kwan Yeoh|
|Mar-2014||Acromio-clavicular joint injuries||Dr Todd Gothelf|
|Feb-2014||Chronic Knee Pain||Dr Paul Annett|
|Dec-2013||Foot and Ankle Questions||Dr John Negrine|
|Oct-2013||Rotator Cuff Repair||Dr Todd Gothelf|
|Sep-2013||ACL Reconstruction||Dr Doron Sher|
|Jul-2013||Slipped Upper femoral epiphysis||Dr Rod Pattinson|
|May-2013||Skiers thumb||Dr Kwan Yeoh|
|Apr-2013||Bakers_Cyst||Dr Ivan Popoff|
|Mar-2013||Tibial Osteotomy vs UKR||Dr Doron Sher|
|Feb-2013||ALIF success rate||Dr Andreas Loefler|
|Jan-2013||Lisfranc Injuries||Dr Todd Gothelf|
|Nov-2012||Anterior Spinal Fusions||Dr Andreas Loefler|
|Oct-2012||MCL Injuries||Dr Doron Sher|
|Sep-2012||Compartment Syndrome||DrPaul Annett|
|Aug-2012||Carpal tunnel||Dr Kwan Yeoh|
|July-2012||Anterior Process Calcaneus Fx||Dr Todd Gothelf|
|Jun-2012||Tenodesis vs Tenotomy||DrJeromeGoldberg|
|May-2012||Osteoarthritis in the young active patient||Dr Doron Sher|
|Apr-2012||Syndesmosis Sprain||Dr Todd Gothelf|
|Mar-2012||Triangular Fiocartilage Injuries||Dr Kwan Yeoh|
|Jan-2012||Shoulder Replacement Older Population||Dr Jerome Goldberg|
|Dec-2011||Wrist Fracture||Dr Kwan Yeoh|
|Nov-2011||Adductor Tendon Tear||Dr Paul Annett|
|Oct-2011||Navicular Pain||Dr Todd Gothelf|
|Sep-2011||OCD Lesion||Dr Doron Sher|
|Aug-2011||Metal on Metal Hip Replacements||Dr Andreas Loefler|
|July-2011||Femoral Neck Stress Fract (Pt 2)||Dr John Best|
|Jun-2011||Femoral Neck Stress Fractures||Dr John Best|
|May-2011||PCL Injury Part 2||Dr Doron Sher|
|Apr-2011||PCL Injury Part 1||Dr DoronSher|
|Mar-2011||Prolotherapy Autologous Blood Injections||DrPaul Annett|
|Feb-2011||Shoulder Impingement||Dr Todd Gothelf|
|Dec-2010||Does Chondral Grafting Work||DrDoron Sher|
|Nov-2010||Shoulder Immobilisation-Dislocation||Dr Jerome Goldberg|
|Sep-2010||SLAP Lesions Stable Shoulder||Dr ToddGothelf|
|Jul-2010||Ankle Sprains||Dr Todd Gothelf|
|Jun-2010||Dislocation After THR||Dr Peter Walker|
|May-2010||Acupuncture Muscle Strength Programmes||Dr Paul Annett|
|April-2010||Full Thickness Rotator Cuff Tears||Dr JeromeGoldberg|
|Mar-2010||Skiing after TKR||Prof Warwick Bruce|
|Feb-2010||Fractures of the Clavicle||Dr John Trantalis|
|Jan-2010||Osteoarthritis of the Knee||Dr Doron Sher|
|Dec-2009||Fifrth Metatarsal Fractures||Dr Todd Gothelf|
|Nov-2009||Partial Rotator Cuff Tears||Dr Todd Gothelf|